At a prior firm, Philip Werner represented Marathon Oil Co. in a contract damage claim against a construction company to recover damages and expenses connected with a crane accident and release of toxic hydrofluoric acid. The accident occurred when a crane that was lifting a piece of heavy equipment dropped the equipment on a tank. The tank, which contained hydrofluoric acid, released the vapors. The hydrofluoric acid vapor release forced a reported 3,000 residents to evacuate the area.
After a trial that lasted nearly three weeks, a Harris County jury found both the defendant, CBI Na-Con, and plaintiff Marathon Oil negligent in connection with the accident. The jury placed 95 percent of the liability for the accident on CBI Na-Con and 5 percent on Marathon Oil. Marathon owned the refinery; CBI Na-Con was its contractor.
The court’s judgment ordered CBI Na-Con to pay Marathon Oil almost $11.9 million in actual damages, another $925,000 under an indemnity agreement, and $10 million in punitive damages. The judgment also ordered CBI Na-Con to pay another $8.4 million in prejudgment interest and court costs. The case received widespread attention, including a detailed report in the Texas Lawyer.